My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

Ask Your Question

WebMD Answers

120 Characters remaining
120 Characters remaining
  • First, try and keep your question as short as possible.
  • Include specific words that will help us identify questions that may already have your answer.
  • If you don't find your answer, you can post your question to WebMD Experts and Contributors.


Posted: | Report This Report Question |

Sister had normal papsmear in 2010. Feb 2012 diagnosed with 3b cervical cancer, died July 30. Papsmear reliability?

My sister was 52 at the time of her death.  She was a smoker.  My other sister also had cervical cancer but had a colposcopy and then 10 years later a hysterectomy.  A familial connection?


Answers From Experts & Organizations (1)

Primary Care
6,467 Answers
72,900 Helpful Votes

I am so sorry to hear about your sisters. Yes, there most definitely may be a familial connection with cervical cancer in your family. This is all the more reason for you to have regular pap smears....pap smears taken and processed properly.

 Pap smears are reliable, but they are only as good as the skill of the person getting the cell specimen, the skill of the lab processing the sample, and the skill of the pathologist reading the slides. If you think that pathologist may have missed it on your sister's last pap, perhaps it would be good to obtain them (the orginal slides or microphotographs) should be kept on file a the pathology facility. Her next of kin may have to request them officially, but I do not see why another, independent pathologist cannot re-read them. Mistakes have been made before, I can assure you.

Reviewing these slides will not bring back your sister, as you know, but it may help you with closure, and give you a bit more confidence with your own pap smear tests. If a cancer was missed, this would be a serious malpractice situation.


This answer should not be considered medical advice...down arrowThis answer should not be considered medical advice and should not take the place of a doctor’s visit. Please see the bottom of the page for more information or visit our Terms and Conditions.up arrow

| Report This Report Answer

Was this helpful?


Thanks for your feedback.

9 of 10 found this helpful